Grid-Tied vs Off-Grid vs Hybrid
If you’re thinking about long-term sustainability and energy efficiency, you’ll want to explore the ins and outs of renewable energy systems. Choosing the right system means minimizing power costs and a good return on your investment in the long run. If you’re considering solar, you next need to decide between the three types of solar systems:
- Off-Grid – also known as a stand-alone power system (SAPS)
- Hybrid – grid-connected solar system with battery storage
- Grid-Tied – also known as an on-grid or grid-feed solar system
Advantages of Off-Grid Systems
Disconnecting from your municipal power company comes with several benefits — no doubt the following advantages play a part in your desire to install an off-grid photovoltaic system:
- Independence — Go with an off-grid system, and you’re no longer subject to the terms and policies of the utility company. Getting away from the ongoing rate increase may be reason enough to cut ties.
- No Blackouts — When the power is out and everyone else has no electricity, your home will still have full power. This can be particularly important for people with health conditions that require electronic devices or refrigerated medicine.
- No Electricity Bills — You’ll never again have to give the utility company a slice of your monthly paycheck after you go off-grid with solar power.
Disadvantages of Off-Grid Systems
Installing an off-grid photovoltaic system does come with some drawbacks, however. Here are a few reasons homeowners end up deciding against going off-grid:
- Higher Initial Cost — If you disconnect fully from the power company, you’ll need a source of backup power for when the sun isn’t shining. Adding a battery bank and/or generator bumps up your solar costs.
- Limited Solar Energy Storage — Even with backup power, energy storage is limited. Given a few days of cloudy weather, you may run out of stored electricity.
- Energy Efficiency is a Must — When you live off-grid, you have to be careful about your household energy use or you run the risk of not having enough power for your home.
Advantages of Hybrid Systems
- You’ll use less grid electricity than you would with a traditional grid-tied system. While hybrid setups are grid-tied, they come with solar battery storage, which means you can maximize the consumption of the power generated from the panels.
- A hybrid system is possibly the most expandable, future-ready home solar setup. With some customizable hybrid systems, you can expand your capacity by buying more panels or batteries. Hybrid systems may also be compatible with newer solar technologies — for example, an electric vehicle (EV) might function as one of the ‘batteries’ in a hybrid setup.
- For even lower costs, you can use a power management system. These technologies can automatically optimize your power usage. (For example, larger appliances like dishwashers can be switched on during peak daylight hours.) The result: bigger utility savings and a quicker ROI.
Some Disadvantages of Hybrid Systems
- There’s a lot to install upfront, making the initial investment bigger. While you can budget for a smaller battery bank than with an off-grid setup, the cost still needs some thought. Specialized equipment, such as a smart hybrid inverter, adds to the price tag.
- Lots of space might be necessary for the required parts. With grid access, you’re likely not in an isolated rural area – even so, you’ll need space for hybrid solar equipment, including the battery bank and inverters.
Advantages of Grid-Tied Systems
- Cost-effective system: there are no expensive batteries.
- Quick return on investment: the typical payback period for a system is 4 to 6 years.
- High reliability: as there are fewer components and system requirements compared to hybrid or off-grid systems.
- Little to no maintenance is required.
Disadvantages of Grid-Tied Systems
- No backup power: there are no batteries and the system is dependent on the grid to work. When there is a grid power failure, the system also shuts down.
- Dependent on a stable grid: if the grid frequency or voltage is outside an acceptable range, the system shuts down.
- Energy production does not match energy usage: solar energy is produced in a typical solar production bell curve, mainly between 9 am and 4 pm. If the energy is not used immediately it is exported. Typically, the tariff earned for exported electricity is lower than the tariff paid for imported / self-consumed electricity.
Langebaan – Vredenburg – Saldanha – Hopefield – St Helena Bay – Velddrif – Jacobs Bay – Moorreesburg – Yzerfontein – Cape Town